XxKnuckleheadxX
Reef enthusiast
chris your could possibly be a carnation its hard to tell with it slumped like that. if it is a carnation those are hard to keep alive. your tank has to be perfect and mature enough for it.
New Colt Coral
- Thread starter Chris_150G
- Start date
Bifferwine
I am a girl
Does it look like this:
http://www.liveaquaria.com/images/categories/product/p-80483-tree-coral.jpg
If so, Knucklehead nailed it -- it's a carnation coral, which is a type of nephthya (as Winy mentioned earlier). Carnations are definitely not easy corals:
It is extremely difficult to maintain in the reef aquarium, and should be housed in an established reef aquarium, by the more advanced marine aquarist. It requires low lighting combined with medium to strong water movement. It is necessary to have a constant current with an abundance of algal plankton. For continued good health, it will also require the addition of strontium, iodine, and other trace elements to the water.
It does not contain the symbiotic algae zooxanthellae. Therefore, its diet should include live, baby brine shrimp, micro-plankton, and other small foods designed for filter feeding invertebrates, in order to survive in the reef aquarium. These foods must be available almost constantly. Again, only expert aquarists should attempt to keep this coral.
http://www.liveaquaria.com/images/categories/product/p-80483-tree-coral.jpg
If so, Knucklehead nailed it -- it's a carnation coral, which is a type of nephthya (as Winy mentioned earlier). Carnations are definitely not easy corals:
It is extremely difficult to maintain in the reef aquarium, and should be housed in an established reef aquarium, by the more advanced marine aquarist. It requires low lighting combined with medium to strong water movement. It is necessary to have a constant current with an abundance of algal plankton. For continued good health, it will also require the addition of strontium, iodine, and other trace elements to the water.
It does not contain the symbiotic algae zooxanthellae. Therefore, its diet should include live, baby brine shrimp, micro-plankton, and other small foods designed for filter feeding invertebrates, in order to survive in the reef aquarium. These foods must be available almost constantly. Again, only expert aquarists should attempt to keep this coral.
Chris_150G
Reefing newb
Carnation? I'm not happy about that. It was still slumped this morning but the polyps are out which shows its still alive. I can't open the liveaquaria link at work so I'll look at that tonight. Thanks peeps.
Chris_150G
Reefing newb
I'm done with that fish shop. They know I'm new to this and don't know how to take care of a it. They sold me, a total rookie, a coral that needs expert care. it needs phyto everyday? I don't want to feed at all! They don't care about the coral or the customers. Also, with the exception of their frag tank, their coral tanks have a massive infestation of Aiptasia. If you live in So California beware of "Pet World" in San Bernardino.
dcantucson
Reef pro
Sorry about your experience Chris. We have all been there before. Don't let it discourage you.
XxKnuckleheadxX
Reef enthusiast
unfortunately it happends all the time. not all shops do that. and being a newb you tend to buy on impulse more then anything. dont take that the wrong way. because ive done it! lol.. but you learned a lesson and gained knowledge from it wich is good. kinda glass half full type of thing? no? lol
Chris_150G
Reefing newb
Yeah its a learning experience for sure. I feel bad that a coral and the last of my coral money were wasted. That thing wasn't cheap. Thats it for me until after xmas.
dcantucson
Reef pro
I hate seeing a Coral die too, but the money that's lost is very frustrating also. Even with easy stuff they die and you shake your head and wonder why. Corals are so sensitive sometimes.
Chris_150G
Reefing newb
It is for sure a carnation. Sol I've decided to drive all the way home to get it and take it back to the fish shop. I'm not going to watch it die.
winyfrog
Yep!
Carnation grow hanging down from ledges and caves, if you place it up on a ledge so the (droopy) part is hanging and give it some good flow, you may be able to keep it healthier longer.
They are a lower light coral and require phytoplankton feedings on a continuous bases.
If you haven't taken it back to the store yet.
They are a lower light coral and require phytoplankton feedings on a continuous bases.
If you haven't taken it back to the store yet.
Chris_150G
Reefing newb
Thanks. I took it back. I wasn't going to feed it like it needed.
My tank doesn't need that right now. I'm going thru salt like crazy already. Maybe if my DSB was matured or I actually received the chaeto I orderd.
I love this site. Thanks for all of the help.
My tank doesn't need that right now. I'm going thru salt like crazy already. Maybe if my DSB was matured or I actually received the chaeto I orderd.
I love this site. Thanks for all of the help.
XxKnuckleheadxX
Reef enthusiast
they trade it? or give you store credit?
yote
In Memoriam
I hate hearing things like that.Buts all to common with this hobby.But then again,the guy at the store may not have known what he was actually selling you.
But either way,I sure hope they at least gave you store credit for it.
But either way,I sure hope they at least gave you store credit for it.
Chris_150G
Reefing newb
No. No credit or even an apology for telling me it was a Colt.
Bifferwine
I am a girl
I think you did the right thing by taking it back. At least you're not responsible for it if it dies now. I think all of us have been misled by LFSs at one point or another -- either intentionally or accidentally. It sucks, especially when it costs you money. Next time you're thinking of buying something, be sure to post about it here first. We'll be happy to let you know what our experiences have been with that animal. Without trying to sell you anything!
yote
In Memoriam
Even snap a shot of whatever it is your looking at with your cell phone.Then you can post the pic here and we'll get you the RIGHT id on it.
dcantucson
Reef pro
Sorry it didn't work out Chris. :(
They should have given you some credit. No loss to them to do that.
They should have given you some credit. No loss to them to do that.
yote
In Memoriam
I think I'd just find another store.
fastrd400
It wasn't me!
+1 to Yote. I can't believe they didn't offer a store credit at least. Now if it survives, they're going to sell the same coral twice. If it was me I'd be in bad mouthing them to the customers as I'm getting something simple like food.
dcantucson
Reef pro
yote I think we all need to shop at your fish store. Seems like it's the only decent one.
Similar threads
