You can also look up Absolutely Fish over in Clifton, HUGE selection of corals. Like, MASSIVE colonies to tiny frags and everything in between :p
3000 Gallons of Saltwater Fish, 3000 Gallons of Freshwater fish, and 1500 Gallons worth of Corals and Inverts. Probably one of the biggest fish stores in Jersey.
Get em small so they most likely wont go for any fish. I would recommend Petco for them. Like 7$ each and they usually have some that are like 1/2" to 1". Grab like 2-3 of them. Just make sure you drip them cause the petcos around us keep their salinity at like 1.021-1.023. I got 2 emeralds and 2 red fiddlers in my 55 :p
Oh, last time I was there I didn't see any emeralds. Glad your sally is helping with your hair algae :). I was suppose to swing by there today since he was getting in his high end stuff... but I ended up being home with my kids while my girl went to work. On the plus side, got a 6 bulb t5ho for my 55, and got the biocube up and running with water and sand. Also has like 10ish lbs of dry rock with 1lbs of live rock. Trying to find someone locally on CL who has a bunch of rock they're looking to sell for 1-2$ a pound lol