Dying shrooms

• Sep 4, 2010

• #1

algy1943

Reefing newb

My red shrooms seem to be dying off yet the green shrooms are getting bigger, could the high nitrates I had have been the cause, they are at 20mg/L now since removing the filter media, doubled up on photo's sorry

 

Last edited: Sep 4, 2010

• Sep 4, 2010

• #2

algy1943

Reefing newb

todays photo of red shroom

 

Last edited: Sep 4, 2010

• Sep 4, 2010

• #3

Smitty

Reef pro

It's possibly the nitrates is causing them to die, or close up. Have you done a water change?

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #4

Bifferwine

I am a girl

I don't see the "today's photo". In the one you posted, they look good.

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #5

algy1943

Reefing newb

Todays photo

algy1943 said:

todays photo of red shroom

Click to expand...

Today's photo of shroom

 

Attachments

• 
  038 shrooms resized.webp

  69.7 KB · Views: 1,196

• Sep 4, 2010

• #6

algy1943

Reefing newb

Smitty said:

It's possibly the nitrates is causing them to die, or close up. Have you done a water change?

Click to expand...

20% weekly

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #7

algy1943

Reefing newb

Bifferwine said:

I don't see the "today's photo". In the one you posted, they look good.

Click to expand...

Photo now added,Sarah BTW did you find your blue zoas that went missing?

 

Last edited: Sep 4, 2010

• Sep 4, 2010

• #8

Bifferwine

I am a girl

No, I never did find them. :(

That's weird about the shrooms. Do they look the same with the lights on and off? Are they in a lot of light, or not very much light?

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #9

OhNoNemo

i love triggers

Maybe too much current also,IDK,but i know my red ones never fully opened till i moved them to a nice calm spot in the tank..seems that way for all my rics and shrooms,but your appeared to be doing fine and now all of a sudden they are not...so IDK

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #10

the reef kid

hi

Yeah, I'm with nemo...how much flow do you have them in?

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #11

yote

In Memoriam

I'm betting that that algae thats growing arond your mushrooms,are whats effecting them.
Step up your water changes to at least 50% twice a week until you get those nitrates down.

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #12

OhNoNemo

i love triggers

What are his trates,and whats consider bad for shrooms...mine have always been around 5-10ppm...since getting my first shrooms a couple months ago they have done nothing but get bigger....crazy ting is,i read on an online forum that some people think shrooms actually do better in a tank with trace amounts of trates...

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #13

Bifferwine

I am a girl

I believe his nitrates used to be 40+, but then he removed his mechanical filtration media, and now it's at 20.

Lots of corals do better in a tank with a small amount of nitrates. But 40 (and even 20) can be too much.

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #14

OhNoNemo

i love triggers

I recall the one guy on another forum saying his were at 10-15 and his shrooms never looked better,
so is it safe to say Algy 's problem is trates

 

• Sep 4, 2010

• #15

algy1943

Reefing newb

Bifferwine said:

No, I never did find them. :(

That's weird about the shrooms. Do they look the same with the lights on and off? Are they in a lot of light, or not very much light?

Click to expand...

closer to the bottom of the tank, same distance from the led's as the green shrooms, they seem to gradually shrivel